You are currently viewing Browning Lotion vs Tanning Oil. Which works better?
Browning Lotion vs Tanning Oil

Browning Lotion vs Tanning Oil. Which works better?

Want to tan your skin but are still confused between a browning lotion and a tanning oil? Don’t worry, after reading this blog post, your doubts will be cleared, and you won’t want to watch or read any YouTube videos or another blog post. 

Let’s dig deep down. 

What is Browning Lotion?

Brownie lotion is a skincare product that offers instant tan to your skin. However, it is important to check whether a particular product is suitable for you or not. Browning lotion may contain ingredients like bronzing and coloring agents that make your skin tan instantly. As per our research, we found few brands offer UV protection. 

What is tannin oil?

Tanning oil is also a skincare product that takes longer to make your skin look tan. As it is an oil, it contains other natural ingredients like carrot seed, avocado, sesame, or coconut oil.

While using the tanning oil, you may feel that it’s not working, but it takes a long time to work. It also provides moisturizing benefits and comes with an SPF factor to protect your skin from harmful UV rays. 

Browning Lotion vs. Tanning Oil. Detailed comparison. 


Tanning oil is a little bit cheaper as compared to browning lotion because it contains a basic formulation of oil and other natural ingredients. Browning lotion can be a little expensive because it contains special tanning ingredients. 

Tanning effect

Browning lotion provides instant tan skin because of its special ingredients, whereas tanning oil takes more time to work. So if you want temporary and instant tanning, then go for browning lotion; otherwise, tanning oil is best. 

Online Reviews 

Both products have positive reviews, but if a person wants instant results, they may give negative reviews to tanning oil. 

Shelf Life

Browning lotion takes more time to expire because it contains stabilizing agents and ingredients, but tanning oil may expire quickly. 


Browning lotion contains ingredients like moisturizer, browning agents, and colorants, whereas tanning oil contains natural ingredients like avocado oil, coconut oil, and aloe vera. 

UV Protection

Generally, browning lotion won’t contain SPF, but tanning oil may contain SPF to protect your skin from harmful UV rays. 

Skin Suitability 

In general, browning lotions are not suitable for sensitive skin types, whereas tanning oil is suitable for almost all skin types. But first, check the ingredients before buying it.


Oil spreads easily as compared to lotion. So if you don’t want to spend more time on this, then tanning oil is an ideal choice. 


Browning lotion requires a more careful application method, and for this, you need to read the “How to Use” guide on the product, but in the case of tanning oil, it’s not like that. So browning lotion is more convenient as compared to tanning oil. 

Duration of Results

Effects of tanning oil more as compared to browning lotion because tanning oil gets absorbed over time with sun exposure whereas browning lotion won’t.

Intent of Use. 

Browning lotion is designed to make your skin tan instantly for a short period whereas tanning oil is made for gradual skin tan and those who want tanned skin for a longer period then they can use tanning oil. 

Also Read: 10 Best tanning bed lotions

Tanning Bed Lotions
This image is all about best tanning beds lotions at an affordable rate

Browning Lotion vs Tanning Oil. Which one should I choose?

If you want tanned skin for a longer period and don’t want instant results then tanning oil is best otherwise browning lotion provides short-span tanned skin instantly. 

Also note that if your budget is tight, tanning oil is a little bit cheaper compared to browning lotion, and also note that most browning lotions won’t come with SPF, but some tanning oil does. So if you want an SPF factor, then choose tanning oil; otherwise, browning lotion works well. 

FAQ on Browning Lotion vs Tanning Oil.

Is it better to tan without tanning oil? 

You can tan without tanning oil, but tanning oil provides a moisturizing effect and protects your skin from sunlight. That’s why it is not recommended. 

Is browning lotion safe to use?

Recently, browning lotion has been linked to accelerating skin cancer. That’s why you should first consult a dermatologist before using any browning lotion.

How long does browning lotion last?

Browning lotion lasts for 3–5 years. 

Is tanning oil safe to use in the sun?

There are very few tanning oils that offer SPF; that’s why it is better to consult with a dermatologist.

Conclusion on Browning Lotion vs. Tanning Oil.

Browning lotion and tanning oil target two different customers. If you want skin tanned instantly and for a short period, then browning lotion is best, whereas if you want gradual tanning without any side effects, then tanning oil is best. However, it is better to get a consultation from your dermatologist before choosing any tanning product. 

Still, if you have any doubts, then comment down below. We will reply as early as possible. 

Thanks for reading. 

Leave a Reply